Amazon Associates PartnerTrusted
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. This helps support our site at no extra cost to you. Clicking on ingredient or equipment links will take you to amazon.com where you can purchase these items.
Homemade Nutter Butter Cookies
A copycat version of the classic Nutter Butter sandwich cookie, made from scratch with a buttery peanut‑butter dough, a soft peanut‑butter‑halva filling, and a hand‑carved wooden stamp for authentic detail. The recipe follows Claire Saffitz’s recreation process, including the craft of making a cookie stamp, low‑temperature baking for crisp edges, and piping the filling into a peanut shape.
Shop all ingredients on Amazon in one click • Printable PDF with shopping checklist
Cost Breakdown
Critical Success Points
- • Carving and sanding the wooden stamp to achieve clean detail
- • Pressing the dough into the stamp while the dough is chilled to retain shape
- • Baking at low temperature (300°F) to prevent spread and preserve the imprint
- • Heating the sugar‑corn‑syrup mixture to exactly 248°F to achieve the right halva texture
- • Piping the filling before it hardens
Safety Warnings
- • Handle the hot sugar syrup with care – it reaches 248°F and can cause severe burns
- • Use caution when carving wood – keep fingers away from sharp tools
- • Do not over‑bake; cookies can become too hard and break easily
☕ 100% Free & Ad-Free Forever! Made by ADHD friends who got lost in recipe videos
We built this because we kept forgetting recipe steps. Help us keep it ad-free & support our caffeine addiction!
You Might Also Like
Similar recipes converted from YouTube cooking videos
Homemade Impossible-Style Plant-Based Burger
Fiery Jalapeno Popper Smash Burger
Ultimate Crispy Fried Chicken
XXL Brownie with Chocolate Ganache and Fresh Cheese Cream
Apple Crumble
