Amazon Associates

Amazon Associates PartnerTrusted

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. This helps support our site at no extra cost to you. Clicking on ingredient or equipment links will take you to amazon.com where you can purchase these items.

Pro Chef Tests.. Adam Ragusea's NY Pizza at Home!

Recipe by Chef James Makinson

A home‑cooked recreation of Adam Ragusea’s decade‑long pizza, using a high‑hydration Italian pizza flour dough, two different tomato sauces and both low‑moisture and fresh buffalo mozzarella. The recipe includes detailed steps for a wet dough, proper fermentation, stone‑baking at 550°F, and tips for achieving a crisp crust and balanced toppings.

MediumItalianServes 4

Shop all ingredients on Amazon in one click • Printable PDF with shopping checklist

Source Video
4h 10m
Prep
1h 14m
Cook
39m
Cleanup
6h 3m
Total

Cost Breakdown

$91.87
Total cost
$22.97
Per serving

Critical Success Points

  • Activating the yeast properly
  • Achieving the correct wet dough consistency
  • First fermentation for full rise
  • Preheating the pizza stone to 550°F
  • Stretching the dough without tearing
  • Baking at high heat for a short time to get a crisp crust

Safety Warnings

  • The pizza stone will be extremely hot (550°F); use oven mitts and handle with care.
  • Steam released when the pizza hits the stone can cause burns; keep face away.
  • Keep yeast out of reach of children.

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about this recipe

Q

What is the cultural significance and history of New York‑style pizza in American‑Italian cuisine?

A

New York‑style pizza originated in the early 1900s with Italian immigrants who adapted Neapolitan pies to the larger, foldable slices favored by New Yorkers. It became a staple street food, known for its thin, crisp yet chewy crust and simple toppings, embodying the fast‑paced city lifestyle.

cultural
Q

What are the traditional regional variations of New York‑style pizza within the United States?

A

While the classic New York slice uses a thin crust, variations include the “Sicilian” square‑pan style with a thicker base, and the “Grandma” pizza, which is a thin, rectangular pie baked in a home oven. Topping choices also vary by borough, from classic mozzarella to pepperoni, sausage, or even white sauce.

cultural
Q

How is New York‑style pizza traditionally served in New York City?

A

In New York City, pizza is typically sold by the slice, folded in half for easy eating on the go. It’s often served with a light drizzle of olive oil, a sprinkle of grated Parmesan, and sometimes a dash of red pepper flakes. The crust is crisp on the bottom and soft enough to fold.

cultural
Q

What occasions or celebrations is New York‑style pizza traditionally associated with in American culture?

A

Pizza is a go‑to food for casual gatherings, movie nights, sports events, and late‑night meals after a night out. It’s also a popular choice for birthday parties, office lunches, and community fundraisers across the United States.

cultural
Q

How does New York‑style pizza fit into the broader Italian‑American cuisine tradition?

A

New York‑style pizza reflects the Italian‑American tradition of adapting Old‑World recipes to New‑World ingredients and larger portions. It bridges Neapolitan techniques (high‑heat stone baking) with American preferences for convenience, making it a cornerstone of Italian‑American comfort food.

cultural
Q

What are the authentic traditional ingredients for New York‑style pizza versus acceptable substitutes?

A

Authentic ingredients include high‑protein “00” or bread flour, San Marzano tomatoes or quality canned tomato puree, low‑moisture mozzarella, and extra‑virgin olive oil. Acceptable substitutes are all‑purpose flour (with added gluten), regular canned diced tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella if well‑drained.

cultural
Q

What other Italian‑American dishes pair well with New York‑style pizza?

A

Classic pairings include Caesar or arugula salad, garlic knots, antipasto platters with cured meats and olives, and a simple tiramisu for dessert. A crisp Italian soda or a glass of Chianti also complements the pizza’s flavors.

cultural
Q

What makes New York‑style pizza special or unique in Italian‑American cuisine?

A

Its hallmark is the high‑hydration dough baked on a scorching stone, producing a crust that’s both crisp and chewy. The thin, foldable slice, minimal toppings, and quick bake time set it apart from thicker, sauce‑heavy regional pies.

cultural
Q

What are the most common mistakes to avoid when making New York‑style pizza at home?

A

Common errors include using too much water (making the dough unmanageable), under‑preheating the stone, over‑loading toppings which sog the crust, and not letting the dough rise long enough. Each of these can lead to a dense or soggy pizza.

technical
Q

Why does this Adam Ragusea inspired pizza recipe use a high‑hydration dough instead of a firmer dough?

A

A high‑hydration dough (≈75% water) creates more steam during baking, which expands the crust and yields the airy, bubbly texture characteristic of New York‑style pizza. A firmer dough would produce a denser, less tender crust.

technical
Q

Can I make the dough ahead of time and how should I store it?

A

Yes. After the first rise, cover the dough tightly and refrigerate for up to 24 hours. Bring it back to room temperature before the second rise and shaping. This slow fermentation improves flavor and makes the dough easier to handle.

technical
Q

What does the YouTube channel Chef James Makinson specialize in?

A

The YouTube channel Chef James Makinson focuses on detailed home‑cooking tutorials, especially classic and modern pizza techniques, bread baking, and Italian‑American comfort foods, with an emphasis on scientific explanations and reproducible results.

channel
Q

How does the YouTube channel Chef James Makinson's approach to pizza making differ from other pizza cooking channels?

A

Chef James Makinson combines rigorous measurement (using scales), high‑quality ingredient sourcing, and step‑by‑step visual explanations, whereas many other channels rely on volume measurements and less precise temperature control. His videos also include troubleshooting and cultural context.

channel

You Might Also Like

Similar recipes converted from YouTube cooking videos

Basil Pesto Pasta Recipe

Basil Pesto Pasta Recipe

A quick, cheap, and delicious Italian-inspired pasta tossed with fresh homemade basil pesto. Perfect for a weeknight dinner for two, this recipe highlights the bright flavor of basil, garlic, Parmesan, and pine nuts without overcooking the herbs.

30 min
Serves 2
$3
0 views
ItalianEasy
Classic Italian Lasagne with Spinach Pasta and Meat Ragu

Classic Italian Lasagne with Spinach Pasta and Meat Ragu

A traditional Italian lasagne featuring a slow‑cooked pork and beef ragu, homemade spinach‑infused pasta sheets, creamy béchamel, mozzarella and Parmesan. Made from scratch for a hearty family dinner that keeps well for leftovers or freezing.

5 hrs 49 min
Serves 8
$28
8 views
ItalianMedium
This Video Almost Broke Me...

This Video Almost Broke Me...

A rustic Italian bread salad featuring toasted stale bread, sweet roasted onions, juicy tomatoes, golden berries, and a vibrant green basil oil. Inspired by the chaotic yet heartfelt Sunday Supper episode of NOT ANOTHER COOKING SHOW, this recipe captures the essence of a traditional Tuscan panzanella while adding a fresh basil‑infused twist.

1 hr 5 min
Serves 10
$28
4 views
ItalianMedium
Pasta e Fagioli 🥣🫘 Bite

Pasta e Fagioli 🥣🫘 Bite

A comforting Italian bean and pasta soup inspired by Stanley Tui's favorite. Made with a classic mirepoix, tomato paste, white wine, and optional ground beef, this hearty bowl is finished with Parmesan and fresh parsley. Serve with crusty bread for a perfect fall meal.

1 hr 10 min
Serves 4
$9
4 views
ItalianMedium
Homemade tomato sauce – 3 variants (herbs, four cheeses, rosé)

Homemade tomato sauce – 3 variants (herbs, four cheeses, rosé)

Learn how to prepare a homemade tomato sauce base from onion, garlic and canned tomatoes, then turn it into three different sauces – with fresh herbs, four cheeses and a creamy rosé. The sauces keep for several months in the refrigerator or freezer, ideal for pasta, pizza and many other preparations.

1 hr 20 min
Serves 8
$8
5 views
ItalianMedium
Creamy Pesto Pasta

Creamy Pesto Pasta

A quick 15‑minute Italian classic: al dente pasta tossed in a silky homemade basil pesto made with toasted pine nuts, garlic, Parmesan, and a splash of pasta water. Perfect for a romantic dinner or a weeknight meal.

30 min
Serves 4
$13
2 views
ItalianEasy