Beurre, huile ou compote : j’ai testé les 3 dans un même gâteau… le résultat est bluffant

Beurre, huile ou compote : j’ai testé les 3 dans un même gâteau… le résultat est bluffant is a medium French recipe that serves 8. 250 calories per serving. Recipe by Hervé Cuisine on YouTube.

Prep: 30 min | Cook: 43 min | Total: 1 hr 28 min

Cost: $25.68 total, $3.21 per serving

Ingredients

  • 150 g All-Purpose Flour (sifted)
  • 150 g Granulated Sugar (fine)
  • 3 large Eggs (room temperature)
  • 1 tsp Baking Powder (double‑acting)
  • 1 pinch Fleur de Sel (optional, enhances flavor)
  • 1 whole Lemon (zested only)
  • 150 g Unsalted Butter (melted)
  • 150 g Vegetable Oil (neutral flavor)
  • 150 g Unsweetened Apple Sauce (smooth, no added sugar)

Instructions

  1. Prepare Ingredients

    Gather all ingredients, zest the lemon directly into the mixing bowl, and set aside.

    Time: PT5M

  2. Whisk Eggs and Sugar

    Add the three eggs and 150 g sugar to the bowl and whisk on medium speed until pale and slightly airy.

    Time: PT5M

  3. Add Salt and Zest

    Stir in the pinch of fleur de sel and the lemon zest until evenly distributed.

    Time: PT2M

  4. Incorporate Dry Ingredients

    Sift the flour and baking powder together, then add to the wet mixture. Mix on low until a smooth batter forms.

    Time: PT5M

  5. Divide Batter

    Weigh the total batter (≈450 g) and split it into three equal portions of 150 g each, placing each portion in a separate bowl.

    Time: PT3M

  6. Add Fat Variant

    To the first bowl stir in the melted butter, to the second stir in the vegetable oil, and to the third stir in the apple sauce. Mix gently until fully incorporated.

    Time: PT5M

  7. Prepare Oven and Pans

    Preheat the oven to 180 °C (convection). Line each cake tin with parchment paper and lightly grease the sides.

    Time: PT5M

    Temperature: 180°C

  8. Bake Cakes

    Pour each batter into its tin and bake. Butter and apple‑sauce cakes for 40 min, oil cake for 43 min, or until a knife inserted in the center comes out clean.

    Time: PT43M

    Temperature: 180°C

  9. Cool and Serve

    Allow the cakes to cool in the tins for 10 min, then turn out onto a cooling rack. Slice and enjoy warm or at room temperature.

    Time: PT10M

Nutrition Facts

Calories
250
Protein
3 g
Carbohydrates
35 g
Fat
10 g
Fiber
0.5 g

Dietary info: Vegetarian, Can be made vegan by using oil or apple sauce and omitting butter

Allergens: Eggs, Wheat, Dairy (butter version)

Last updated: April 6, 2026

Amazon Associates

Amazon Associates PartnerTrusted

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. This helps support our site at no extra cost to you. Clicking on ingredient or equipment links will take you to amazon.com where you can purchase these items.

Beurre, huile ou compote : j’ai testé les 3 dans un même gâteau… le résultat est bluffant

Recipe by Hervé Cuisine

A side‑by‑side comparison of three identical lemon cakes made with equal parts flour, eggs, sugar and a different fat: melted butter, neutral vegetable oil, or unsweetened apple sauce. The classic 4/4 ratio (150 g each) is used, plus baking powder, a pinch of fleur de sel and fresh lemon zest. Bake all three at 180 °C and discover how the fat choice affects rise, texture and flavor.

MediumFrenchServes 8

Shop all ingredients on Amazon in one click • Printable PDF with shopping checklist

Source Video
40m
Prep
43m
Cook
10m
Cleanup
1h 33m
Total

Cost Breakdown

$25.68
Total cost
$3.21
Per serving

Critical Success Points

  • Divide the batter into three equal portions to ensure each cake receives the same amount of base ingredients
  • Incorporate the chosen fat (butter, oil, or apple sauce) gently to avoid deflating the batter
  • Do not over‑bake; check each cake with a knife for doneness

Safety Warnings

  • Handle the hot oven and melted butter with care to avoid burns
  • Use a sharp knife cautiously when testing cake doneness

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about this recipe

Q

What is the cultural significance and history of the 4/4 lemon cake in French home baking?

A

The 4/4 ratio (equal parts flour, sugar, eggs and fat) is a classic French home‑baking principle that dates back to early 20th‑century cake recipes, offering a simple, balanced batter for quick cakes. It is often used for simple sponge‑type cakes and is popular in French family kitchens for its ease and versatility.

cultural
Q

What are the traditional regional variations of a 4/4 cake in French cuisine?

A

In northern France, the 4/4 cake is often flavored with butter and vanilla, while in the south, citrus zest (lemon or orange) and a splash of olive oil are common. Some regions substitute the fat with fruit purées like apple or pear to create lighter, lower‑fat versions.

cultural
Q

How is the 4/4 lemon cake traditionally served in France?

A

It is typically served as an afternoon tea cake, sliced into wedges and enjoyed with a cup of café au lait or tea. A light dusting of powdered sugar or a drizzle of lemon glaze is sometimes added for extra brightness.

cultural
Q

During which French celebrations is the 4/4 cake commonly prepared?

A

The 4/4 cake appears at informal family gatherings, birthdays, and regional festivals such as the Fête de la Gastronomie, where simple, home‑made desserts are highlighted.

cultural
Q

What authentic ingredients are essential for a traditional French 4/4 cake versus acceptable substitutes?

A

Authentic ingredients include all‑purpose flour, granulated sugar, fresh eggs, unsalted butter, baking powder, fleur de sel, and lemon zest. Acceptable substitutes are vegetable oil for butter, or unsweetened apple sauce for a lower‑fat version, and fine sea salt can replace fleur de sel.

cultural
Q

What other French dishes pair well with a lemon‑flavored 4/4 cake?

A

A lemon 4/4 cake pairs nicely with a dollop of crème fraîche, a scoop of vanilla ice cream, or a glass of crisp French white wine such as Sauvignon Blanc. It also complements a light fruit salad featuring berries or stone fruits.

cultural
Q

What makes the 4/4 lemon cake special or unique in French cake tradition?

A

Its simplicity—equal weights of the four core ingredients—creates a balanced texture that is moist yet light. The ratio allows easy experimentation with different fats, as demonstrated in this crash test, while still delivering a classic French sponge feel.

cultural
Q

What are the most common mistakes to avoid when making the 4/4 lemon cake?

A

Common errors include over‑mixing the batter, which can develop gluten and make the cake dense, using expired baking powder, and adding the fat too early which can deflate the incorporated air. Also, baking at too high a temperature can cause the top to brown before the interior is cooked.

technical
Q

Why does this 4/4 cake recipe use a separate mixing step for each fat variant instead of mixing all together?

A

Separating the fats allows a direct comparison of how butter, oil, and apple sauce each affect rise, crumb and flavor. Mixing them together would mask these differences and defeat the purpose of the crash‑test experiment.

technical
Q

Can I make the 4/4 lemon cake ahead of time and how should I store it?

A

Yes, the cakes can be baked a day ahead. Cool completely, then wrap each cake tightly in plastic wrap and store in the refrigerator for up to four days. For longer storage, freeze wrapped slices for up to two months and thaw at room temperature before serving.

technical
Q

What texture and appearance should I look for when the 4/4 lemon cake is done?

A

The cake should be golden‑brown on top, spring back lightly when pressed, and a thin knife inserted in the centre should come out clean. The crumb should be moist, tender, and slightly airy, with visible lemon zest specks.

technical
Q

What does the YouTube channel Hervé Cuisine specialize in?

A

The YouTube channel Hervé Cuisine specializes in practical French home‑cooking tutorials, often featuring experimental “crash test” videos that compare multiple variations of a single recipe to illustrate how ingredient changes affect the final result.

channel
Q

How does the YouTube channel Hervé Cuisine's approach to French baking differ from other French cooking channels?

A

Hervé Cuisine focuses on side‑by‑side scientific comparisons, using identical base recipes and altering one variable at a time. This method provides clear visual evidence of how each change impacts texture, flavor, and appearance, which is less common on more narrative‑driven French cooking channels.

channel

You Might Also Like

Similar recipes converted from YouTube cooking videos

Bec Boka with lamb tripe, intestines and vegetables
7

Bec Boka with lamb tripe, intestines and vegetables

A traditional Algerian dish of lamb tripe and intestines simmered in tomato sauce with chickpeas, zucchini and fragrant spices. Meticulous cleaning of the offal, pressure‑cooking for optimal tenderness, and finishing with fresh coriander.

2 hrs 4 minServes 3$16
Algerian
I Tested The World's Best Noodles
14

I Tested The World's Best Noodles

A recreation of the massive, chewy, hand‑pulled Biang Biang noodles that Joshua Weissman praised as the ultimate noodle experience in Xi'an, China. The noodles are seasoned with a simple salty‑spicy sauce that lets the noodle texture shine.

1 hr 30 minServes 2$3
Chinese
Il faut absolument tester les tortillas de cette façon 👩🏻‍🍳
6

Il faut absolument tester les tortillas de cette façon 👩🏻‍🍳

Crispy corn tortilla cones brushed with egg wash, sprinkled with sesame seeds, and baked until golden. They are filled with a savory mixture of ground beef, mushrooms, green onions, herbs, and melt‑in cheese. Perfect as an appetizer, side dish, or party snack.

58 minServes 4$39
Mexican
The GREATEST SANDWICHES EVER MADE from vegetables
6

The GREATEST SANDWICHES EVER MADE from vegetables

A plant‑based take on the classic deli roast‑beef sandwich using pepper‑crusted celeriac and rutabaga that are roasted, smoked, and sliced ultra‑thin. Served on toasted whole‑grain bread with caramelized onions, vegan cheese, pickles, lettuce, and a tangy mayo‑mustard spread.

5 hrs 50 minServes 4$58
American
VEGAN GOCHUJANG BUTTERED NOODLES (NYT Greatest 50 Recipes Veganized)
2

VEGAN GOCHUJANG BUTTERED NOODLES (NYT Greatest 50 Recipes Veganized)

A quick, low‑effort vegan take on the viral Korean buttered noodles. Spaghetti tossed in a savory, slightly sweet gochujang sauce with garlic, vegan butter, and optional green onion and black sesame garnish.

25 minServes 2$3
Korean
CAROLINA REAPER BONELESS WINGS CHALLENGE │ WORLD'S HOTTEST PEPPER!!!
1

CAROLINA REAPER BONELESS WINGS CHALLENGE │ WORLD'S HOTTEST PEPPER!!!

A tongue‑tingling, ultra‑spicy wing challenge using boneless chicken wings from Wing Stop tossed in a fiery sauce packed with 12 Carolina Reaper peppers, habanero seasoning, and a blend of hot sauces and spices. Perfect for heat‑seekers who want a true Carolina Reaper experience without the mess of bone‑in wings.

47 minServes 4$58
American