How To Make The Best Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches! (Big Backtivities)
How To Make The BEST Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches! (Big Backtivities) is a easy American recipe that serves 6. 300 calories per serving. Recipe by Koreanosh on YouTube.
Prep: 20 min | Cook: 30 min | Total: 55 min
Cost: $21.26 total, $3.54 per serving
Ingredients
- 1 pint Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream (softened slightly for cutting)
- 4 pieces Subway Double Chocolate Cookie (store‑bought, room temperature)
- 4 pieces Subway Chocolate Chip Cookie (store‑bought, room temperature)
- 4 pieces Subway Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie (store‑bought, room temperature)
Instructions
Gather Ingredients and Equipment
Collect ice cream, three varieties of Subway cookies, a sharp knife, cutting board, tray, and parchment paper.
Time: PT5M
Soften Ice Cream
Remove the ice cream tub from the freezer and let it sit at room temperature for about 5 minutes until slightly softened but still firm.
Time: PT5M
Cut Ice Cream into Pucks
Place the tub on the cutting board. Using the knife, cut the ice cream into 1‑inch thick rounds (pucks) roughly the size of the cookies.
Time: PT5M
Assemble Sandwiches
Lay a cookie flat on the tray, place an ice‑cream puck on top, then cover with a second cookie. Press gently so the ice cream spreads to the edges but the cookies stay intact.
Time: PT5M
Freeze to Set
Transfer the assembled sandwiches to the freezer. Freeze for at least 30 minutes until the ice cream hardens again.
Time: PT30M
Clean Up
Wash the knife, cutting board, and any other used utensils. Wipe the tray.
Time: PT5M
Nutrition Facts
- Calories
- 300
- Protein
- 5 g
- Carbohydrates
- 35 g
- Fat
- 15 g
- Fiber
- 2 g
Dietary info: Vegetarian
Allergens: Dairy, Gluten, Peanuts, Soy
Ingredient Substitutions
- Instead of Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream: any creamy ice cream flavor
- Instead of Subway Double Chocolate Cookie: any double chocolate cookie
- Instead of Subway Chocolate Chip Cookie: any chocolate chip cookie
- Instead of Subway Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie: any raspberry or cheesecake flavored cookie
Equipment Needed
- Knife
- Cutting Board
- Freezer‑Safe Tray
- Parchment Paper (optional)
- Spatula (optional)
Critical Steps — Do Not Skip
- Soften Ice Cream
- Cut Ice Cream into Pucks
- Assemble Sandwiches
Chef Tips from the Video
- For a cleaner edge, dip the knife in hot water before each cut.
- If you want a firmer sandwich, freeze the assembled sandwiches for 45 minutes instead of 30.
- Add a drizzle of chocolate sauce after freezing for extra indulgence.
Troubleshooting
Ice cream melts too quickly while assembling.
Return the pucks to the freezer for a few minutes between each sandwich.
Cookies crumble or break under pressure.
Press gently and use slightly softened (not melted) ice cream; you can also chill the cookies briefly.
Storage
Refrigerator: Can be kept for up to 24 hours but texture will soften.
Freezer: Best stored in an airtight container for up to 2 weeks.
Room temperature: Serve at room temperature for 2‑3 minutes for optimal softness.
Make-Ahead Tips
- Assemble the sandwiches a day ahead and keep them sealed in the freezer.
- Wrap each sandwich in parchment or plastic wrap to prevent freezer burn.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cultural significance and history of ice cream sandwich desserts in American cuisine?
Ice cream sandwiches have been a beloved American treat since the early 1900s, originally made with soft homemade cookies or wafers. They became popular at fairs and later as packaged snacks, symbolizing a simple, portable indulgence for both kids and adults.
How did Subway cookies become a popular choice for homemade ice cream sandwiches?
Subway introduced its soft, bakery‑style cookies in the early 2000s, and their consistent texture and sweet flavor made them an easy, store‑bought alternative to baking cookies from scratch, perfect for quick ice cream sandwich creations.
What occasions or celebrations are ice cream cookie sandwiches traditionally associated with in the United States?
They are often served at summer barbecues, birthday parties, and casual gatherings because they are easy to make, handheld, and can be customized with different cookie and ice‑cream flavors.
What regional variations of ice cream sandwiches exist within American cuisine?
Beyond classic chocolate chip cookies, some regions favor brownies, peanut butter cookies, or even corn‑flake coated wafers. In the South, pecan pie ice cream between shortbread cookies is a favorite, while the West Coast loves matcha or oat‑milk ice cream with vegan cookies.
What makes the Subway Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches unique compared to traditional homemade ice cream sandwiches?
Using pre‑made Subway cookies saves time and guarantees a soft, uniform cookie, while the Peanut Butter S'mores ice cream adds a rich, salty‑sweet flavor that isn’t typical of classic vanilla or chocolate ice cream sandwiches.
How does the Subway Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches recipe fit into the broader American dessert tradition?
It embodies the American love for convenience, indulgence, and remixing familiar flavors—combining a popular fast‑food bakery item with a premium ice‑cream brand to create a nostalgic yet modern treat.
What are the authentic traditional ingredients for an ice cream sandwich versus acceptable substitutes?
Traditionally, a soft cookie or wafer and a vanilla or chocolate ice cream are used. Acceptable substitutes include any flavored ice cream (like Peanut Butter S'mores) and any soft cookie (such as Subway’s double chocolate, chocolate chip, or raspberry cheesecake).
What are the most common mistakes to avoid when making Subway Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches?
The biggest errors are letting the ice cream melt too much before cutting, pressing the cookies too hard and breaking them, and not allowing enough freezing time for the sandwiches to set.
Why does this recipe use a short 5‑minute softening step instead of fully thawing the ice cream?
A brief softening makes the ice cream pliable enough to cut cleanly while keeping it firm enough to hold its shape, preventing the pucks from becoming mushy during assembly.
Can I make the Subway Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches ahead of time and how should I store them?
Yes, assemble the sandwiches and keep them sealed in an airtight container in the freezer. They will stay fresh for up to two weeks; bring them to room temperature for a few minutes before serving for optimal texture.
What does the YouTube channel Koreanosh specialize in?
The YouTube channel Koreanosh focuses on Korean and Asian-inspired comfort foods, street‑food recreations, and easy‑to‑follow home cooking tutorials that blend traditional flavors with modern twists.
How does the YouTube channel Koreanosh's approach to snack‑style desserts differ from other cooking channels?
Koreanosh emphasizes quick, minimal‑prep desserts using readily available store‑bought items, often incorporating Korean flavor elements or popular snack brands, whereas many other channels focus on from‑scratch baking or elaborate plating.
Last updated: August 29, 2026
